So, there's a problem with the new Strokes music video, and unfortunately that problem is me.
Hi everyone, Anthony Fantano here, internet's busiest music nerd. I hope you're doing well. And once again, we have to talk about one of my all-time indie rock faves, The Strokes.
Digging deeper into a beef that unfortunately is growing like an unruly tumor instead of just going away like it should. Because this past weekend, The Strokes just performed on SNL, which it's always nice to see an artist you've been listening to for decades make it onto that platform regardless of where they are in their career.
But then I thought, shit, these guys have a new album out. That album features a song where Julian Casablancas is dissing me. And because that song is one of the most popular tracks on the record, it's about a 90% likelihood that they were gonna play it. And yeah, they did.
Fortunately though, last minute, Julian swapped my name out. For, none other than, publication, rock publication of note, Rolling Stone, who also panned Reality Awaits, though did, so much more gently than I did with a three out of five star rating. And honestly, in a way, it was a little bit of a relief. Cause Lord knows I don't need, another wave of people in my comments quoting the song to me over and over. But also seeing Julian switch these terms in and out made it feel like, eh, maybe the attack isn't really as personal as some, might've read it to be originally. And I'm just merely being used as a stand-in for overly negative critics, a stereotype that long precedes the existence of me.
Unfortunately though, The Strokes also used this media bump as an opportunity to drop a new music video for this song as well. And yeah, I'm freakin' in it. I'm in the music video. Not literally. I'm not literally depicted in the music video. I'm really actually more of, a puppet? Yeah, I'm a puppet in the new music video. And my first reaction to that was, honestly, I thought it was as flattering as being immortalized in the song itself. Especially considering, I guess, the puppets are connected to this massive satirical television program out of the UK called Spitting Image, which has been a thing since the 80s and has undergone a pretty successful reboot as of late.
And honestly, my puppet was far from the most unflattering portrayal in the music video. I certainly looked better than the repurposed Boris Johnson Bach puppet I was standing opposite to. And yeah, I thought my overall appearance in the video was pretty silly and lighthearted. Cause, once again, I am criticizing, the musical creativity of Bach himself and then getting shoved out of frame, very violently. Which is not only funny as a gag, but doubly it is funny that I continue to take up this much space in The Strokes‘ canon.
So I mean, cool. After having seen this over the weekend, for the most part, I was just kind of ready to let it slide.
That is until I started seeing takes like this one.
"You've become the poster boy for a critical collective that popularizes the negative perception of art that dares to challenge the norm. The Strokes are calling out the hive mind you represent."
UGH, which UGH. Negativity toward art that challenges the norm? Really? How? By poorly using one of the most popular vocal effects of the past 20 years?
I'm sorry, I've said this time and time again. I will say it one more time. I love The Strokes. They have made some of my favorite records of all time in rock. But if your read of them is rock band that challenges the norm, you may be listening to rock music at a fourth grade reading level. I'm sorry.
For the love of God. Listen to anything that is even remotely subversive or experimental. In fact, it's hard to name rock albums in the underground that aren't more socially urgent and aesthetically subversive than the new Strokes album. The new Olivia Tremor Control, the new Piss, the new Tropical Fuck Storm, the new Standing on the Corner, the new Protomartyr, the new Mandy, Indiana, the new Guerilla Toss, Sumac and Moor Mother, anything from The Locust, anything from Boredoms, like I could name dozens of artists that are far more out there than The Strokes.
But it's not a competition and it doesn't matter because the reasons I enjoy the Strokes isn't because I think their music is the weirdest, most wild out there rock music that's ever been recorded. If that's what your enjoyment of The Strokes is contingent on, I feel like you've lost the plot a little bit. In a way, Reality Awaits is a fitting title because reality does, in fact, await those who are still willing to take a bullet for this album.
But yeah, not only did many people agree with this take, but there were thousands of others that echoed that this sentiment was an example of media literacy. First off, hive mind accusations from fan accounts is crazy. You run a fan account, you are literally self-selecting for having below average critical thinking skills than the rest of the populace. But considering this was like the takeaway that some people were having from this music video, I started thinking a little bit different about how others might be seeing my character in it.
Because at the end of the day, why am I even in this video? Sure, you could say, well, you're mentioned in the lyrics, but so is Josh Groban and so is The Weeknd and they're not in the music video. And that's because for the most part, the music video is a lampoon of the billionaires and ghouls that are running and ruining our society by spreading disinformation, building data centers, and cutting food in aid for starving children.
There's even a whole section of the video about Greta Thunberg being taken by Israeli fascists for fighting in the name of Palestine. And when I think about it a little bit more, my inclusion here in that context is a bit more disturbing. Because even if this little Bach interaction is meant to be a silly aside in the midst of it all, I still am being put shoulder to shoulder in a way with like the very people who are burning the planet to the ground just for their own benefit. And I don't know, hot take, but I don't think I'm as evil as Elon Musk.
And even if this jab is meant to stop short of, “well, this guy is misinformed and a blowhard like many other names and faces in mainstream media are,” well, even that is an irony right there. Especially since The Strokes are the band who earlier this year were shown to have a media campaign running in their name through YTK, where short-form influencers were being paid to talk favorably about Julian Casablancas’ dissing me on the album and making sure that whatever content was made on this topic had no negative slant against The Strokes in it.
I did a video about it. I have copies of the messages that were sent to reach out to influencers to make this content happen. So yeah, very cool of you guys to go after a critic doing a music video decrying the creation of propaganda while literally having propaganda made in your name. Now, to be fair, when reached out for comment, The Strokes denied having anything to do with the creation of these videos.
But look, in the meantime, I have a new interview show that I'm starting that we just dropped a very nice trailer for that's getting very well received. And as I have said in public and in private, Julian is more than welcome to be a guest on the show and talk with me about this and anything else he wants to hash it out over if he will just stop being a wiener about it.
But whatever, yeah, I'm in the new Strokes music video. Fun times. Fun times in 2026.
Anthony Fantano, The Strokes, forever.
What do you think?
Show comments / Leave a comment