Hi everyone, Twisthony Teenstano here, the internet's busiest music nerd, and it's time for a review of this new album from Twisted Teens, The Holy Cross Tigers.
Yes, this is the newest and third album to drop this year from New Orleans rock duo Twisted Teens, who are looking more and more like a full band these days if you catch them live, especially since this big bump that they just got from the legendary Sub Pop Records, for dropping this new album here, but I'm kind of getting ahead of myself because let's start instead with me even knowing who Twisted Teens is as I reviewed their album Florida Water Blues, the second record they put out this year several months ago, and truth be told there were few rock albums to drop in 2026 that stopped me in my tracks in the way this one did.
Because with this thing you have some really nice, quality, aggro, lo-fi, garage punk with a bluesy twist, thanks mostly to the singing, songwriting, and guitar work of Caspian Hollywell. But then, additionally, Twisted Teens have this backwater country component to most of their songs because of RJ Santos's pedal steel. And if you liked Florida Water Blues at the time that it came out, there was more where it came from! A 2024 album, as well as the Blame the Clown record that dropped just in February of this year.
Which, sure, you could peg as being a little too samey in tone and sound when comparing it to Florida Water Blues, but what it lacked in the harmony and finesse that Florida Water Blues has certainly made up for in explosivity and crunchy distortion and some quirky charm too. And the duo's catchy songwriting shines through all of that weirdness anyway. But again, now we have the Holy Cross Tigers, which makes Twisted Teens' third album this year on another label, three different labels. Three albums, three labels.
Regardless, the end result has been an immense amount of buzz, sold-out shows, all for a band that was a relative unknown just a year ago. And again, for those who are not big fans of lo-fi rock music, for sure you could listen to these records and say they're too compressed, they're too blown out, they're too messy. And from here, who's to know how Twisted Teens' sound is ultimately going to shake out and evolve?
But the truth is the duo probably couldn't have amassed all of this material in such a short time if they were trying to put out the most perfectly assembled, prim combination of songs with an unblemished, pristine sound on each track.
So even if none of these albums are perfect and weren't meant to be, they were all clearly a part of some greater flood-the-zone strategy that most definitely worked. That being said, so much material in such a short period of time can be both a blessing and a curse, especially when one of those albums is most likely going to be a top ten for me this year because there's only so many chord progressions and sounds and washes of fuzz and vocal lines a single band can develop in just months of time. So with three albums, you definitely run the risk of painting yourself into a corner a little bit.
And I was hearing inklings of that on the teaser tracks to this new album, like the opening track "Stalks," which is a mid-paced rocker that feels like a distant cousin to at least a handful of tracks from Blame the Clown and Florida Water Blues, save for the weirdly psychedelic pedal steel solo that makes for the most memorable point on the song.
And of course, there's a lot of crossover on the track "When We First Met," too. A moment whose sameness doesn't disappoint me as much as the performance, which kind of feels like the band is in a rush to just get the whole thing finished and over with. The song would be a complete blur if not for Hollywell's very distinct, soulful, raspy lead vocals and really some of the most adorable lyrics on the entire album. And while I did end up liking this record overall, the rest of the track list is a bit of a mixed bag.
"Be An Angel" is a real low point for me, maybe the most tedious set of chords on the record that resolve very weirdly. There's not much of a hook to speak of on this track either, and you have these buildup moments that only circle back into the original verse chords so unceremoniously. There's "Blue Rose," too, which I do think rocks, but how many non-stop lo-fi trains does this band have in their catalog so far? At least several. A track like "Guided Thunder," for example, sounds like a religious experience in comparison with this one.
I do, however, get quite a bit out of "I Spend My Time Crying," with those sticky guitar leads and melodramatically sad sack lyrics. It's a track that stings but also feels a little tongue-in-cheek at the same time. And yet, it somehow works.
Following this, we do have an interesting little electronic synthy interlude – and while many might disregard this track as, sort of, a forgettable moment that passes by, a mere sonic break. For me, it feels almost like a little lost potential for this album because, in order to diversify their sound, why not incorporate some of these synthesizers, some of these spookier beats and tones to break these tracks up and give The Holy Cross Tigers a new flavor? It's a side dish of an interlude when it could have been more of a factor in the main course.
The rest of the record is able to dish out a few more highlights. "I Bring" is a track that is compressed so much it is bursting at the seams. And lyrically, the track is also bursting at the seams with rejection, talking about bringing another person rings and jokes and them showing no interest. Which fits very snugly into this bittersweet rocker formula that Twisted Teens do so well.
But then "Lock And Key" is actually one of the cooler surprises on the entire record. The chords almost sound like a mutant spin on something a 60s garage rock band would do if they were told to write a Russian rock song or rock that sounds like it's straight out of the Eastern Bloc. But then pair that with some country words and lyrics that are all about some witness of something being pressed by police in an interrogation. And then painting this person as a snitch, a rat who goes on to live another day. Then from here the final moments of the record are a little ramshackle.
You've got moments that come across to me as feeling very off-the-cuff songwriting-wise, and while I understand a big part of Twisted Teens' creative process is literally just recording and performing these somewhat unplanned jams and then formulating songs around those ideas and recordings. Which I think can certainly lead to exciting and very lightning-in-a-bottle energy on these tracks. But it can also lead to redundancies and lyrical ideas that kind of feel like bridges to nowhere. Or structures that are flapping in the wind or struggling to kind of fill enough gaps to create some semblance of a complete song.
"Figure It Out" comes across that way to my ears as well as "Armed With A Vision," which ironically doesn't have much vision as to where the song should go next outside of the kind of main groove that it hits you with once it really gets going.
There are a few more pleasantly strange surprises in the tracklist, though. With "Every Flower," those synthesizers I was talking about earlier actually do play a little bit of a role in the intro. The lyrics feature all of these poetic reflections on death that are backed by these very slow, almost sludgy riffs. Weary vocals, too. It's one of Caspian's most theatrical and shaken performances on the record for sure.
And then with the closing track, "Darker The Night Is The Brighter I See," it's almost like this campfire acoustic sing-along with lots of group vocals, peppy chords, and it's one of the sweeter moments on the entire album and a show of the versatility that Twisted Teens could have if they were just more willing on this record to shake it up.
Which, again, given my familiarity with the past two albums they dropped this year, I was kind of hoping for. However, I could see them wanting to play it a little straighter on this album, given that it is a sub-pop release and most likely would be the biggest introduction they would have in 2026 through a label release. So again, my criticisms of this album are there, but also, coming from a place of understanding the strategy they were going for with releasing all of these records in such a short succession of time.
Because regardless of how good this album is or isn't, in my eyes or your eyes, personally, I think it's the weakest of the three they dropped this year. But it's still pretty solid overall, features quite a few songs that I liked, and was an effective part of a very interesting rollout strategy that was undeniably effective this year.
Would I say try this album? Sure. It's probably not a bad introduction to Twisted Teens and their sound, their style, what they do. But don't be surprised if, once you hear this, you hit rewind and find some of the songwriting or the energy on Blame The Clown or Florida Water Blues to be a little bit better. Which is why I'm feeling a light to decent 7 on this album.
Anthony Fantano. Twisted Teens. Forever.
What do you think?
Show comments / Leave a comment